550 Madison Street in Greenport offers old farmhouse vibes with a bright, new interior. (Photo credit: Jeremy Garretson)


 

The nuts and bolts

3 bedrooms

2 full baths

1 half bath

1,500 square feet

House proud

Built in 2025, this home is farmhouse-flair on the outside and modern chic on the inside. It punches above its weight in terms of details and finishes that give it a stylish presentation. 

“What makes it such a dream house is the way it delivers new construction comfort while still feeling connected to the charm and rhythm of Greenport,” says Jerry Cibulski, the agent at Century 21 Albertson Realty who is listing the property. “The curated accessories and finishes took away the ‘vanilla box’ quality and made this a charming home. It has the comfortable feel of an older home without the maintenance.”

What’s the plan?

Entering the home through a small covered porch, the foyer leads into an open format for the living room, kitchen and dining area. There is a half bath off the foyer and a utility/laundry room off the kitchen. Three bedrooms, including the ensuite primary are upstairs, with the two guest rooms sharing a full bathroom.

What’s cooking?

The kitchen features white shaker-style cabinetry, quartz counters and a porcelain farmhouse sink. Some of the new stainless-steel appliances are integrated with cabinet panels. There are white oak floors throughout. A glass wall of sliders overlooking the back yard lets in plenty of light.

What else?

The backyard will be fully finished with a patio and entertainment area for dining and gathering around the firepit. Cibulski says other on-site projects, such as a pool and other entertainment options, and/or a shed, may be developed, creatively priced and negotiated with the seller. 

One cool thing

The backyard abuts a maple tree forest, offering a quiet, bucolic green space while still in a village-adjacent setting. The Monsell Trail is just behind the home, offering about half a mile of a low-grade walking path, and adjacency to restored wetlands near Silver Lake as part of the public trails project linking the Peconic Bay to Long Island Sound.

Agent’s callout 

“Tucked alongside the woods with access to the trail, the home offers that rare blend of privacy, nature and village convenience, where a morning walk, a bike ride to the beach, or coffee at Aldo’s can all become part of the everyday lifestyle,” Cibulski says.

 

Location, location, location

The home is slightly northwest about .6 mile of the center of Greenport Village and .7 from the North Ferry to Shelter Island. 

Details

The home at 550 Madison Ave., lists for $1,377,000 and the details can be seen here.