The nuts and bolts

2 bedrooms

2 baths

1,100 square feet

.06 acres

House proud

Built in 1905 and completely renovated in 2023, this vintage-modern cottage is so close to the water, it’s like being on a houseboat. But without the rocking, unpredictable weather events and the annoying seagulls. 

What’s the plan?

The one-story house is the epitome of a clean, well-lighted place, with oversized windows overlooking the bay, a vaulted ceiling to add height and light and a custom, streamlined kitchen with a Scandinavian vibe. 

“The owner is an interior designer and wanted to [home] in on the materials that might have been used originally and in an very organic way,” says Bridget Elkin, the Compass agent listing the property. “While it’s small scale, it is very well designed to minimize clutter and maintenance.”

The kitchen and dining area are adjacent to the open living room so that no matter where you sit, there are expansive water views. Off the main common rooms are two bedrooms, each with its own bathroom done in custom tile. 

What’s cooking?

The galley-style kitchen features pretty honey-toned wood cabinetry topped with a stainless steel counter. The sleek design is further enhanced by integrated appliances, such as an induction cooktop, which minimize the footprint. It’s compact, yet offers plenty of storage and countertop space for meal preparation and entertaining. 

What else?

Floating shelves have been built in hallway nooks or alcoves, giving the home a bespoke look.

Amenities and more

• Wraparound deck
• Private sandy beach area
• Grilling area
• Ensuite bedrooms

One cool thing

There’s an unobstructed view of Long Beach Bar Lighthouse (aka Bug Light) as well as Shelter Island.

Agent’s callout 

“This is a simple house by the sea with serene views,” Elkin says. “Water views are scientifically proven to relax you: They have a real pull and there’s no denying that here.” She notes “this block of homes had once been humble fishing cottages that have been brought to their next chapters throughout the years.” 

Location, location, location

With the Peconic Bay at the front and Lake Marion at the back, there truly is water, water all around this home. It is equidistant — 3.2 miles — to the towns of Orient and Greenport, which offer shopping and dining. Also of interest in the area are Old Schoolhouse Park, Norman E. Klipp Marine Park, the Ruth Oliva Preserve at Dam Pond and Truman’s Beach. Golfers and sailors have Island’s End Golf & Country Club, Orient Yacht Club and oenophiles have the North Fork Wine Route, just .25 mile from the home where Bay Avenue joins Route 25.

Details

The home at 2400 Bay Ave., East Marion lists for $1,495,000 and the details can be seen here.