Sign up for our Newsletter

Wondering what your budget can get you on the red-hot East End real estate market? We’re here to help, home buyers.

Tucked into the East End of Long Island, Shelter Island has a calm atmosphere with diverse residents. Properties on the Island not only range in price but in style, making it an area filled with variation and culture. This week we’re featuring homes with both a fireplace and a pool so you’ll be satisfied no matter the weather.


Modern shoreline waterfront 

This property rests at the shoreline of Gardiners Bay with panoramic views and impeccable modern architecture. This seven bedroom and six-and-a-half bathroom home comes with a spacious great room, three bathroom balconies, a double-sided fireplace reaching the kitchen and den, and a heated Gunite pool adjacent to a residential pool house with water views. This house is listed at $8,000,000 by Melina Wein with M. Wein Realty Inc.

Expansive beach house

Located at Reel Point on Ram Island, this mid-century modern home has 180-degree visibility of Gardiners Bay, allowing all four bedrooms in the home to have water views. Not only does this one-acre property have a library next to the living room, but it also has a Ram Island firestone fireplace and a Gunite pool with views of the saltwater. This house is listed at $4,950,000 by Penelope Moore with Sounders & Associates.

Shelter Island traditional 

Located on the historic Westmoreland Farms Peninsula, this four-level home has more than a few luxuries. The five-bedroom and four-and-a-half bathroom property has a tennis court, a wrap-around elevated deck with panoramic views, three libraries, two fireplaces, a Gunite pool and an art studio with a full bath and bird’s eye view of the water. This house is listed at $4,325,000 by Penelope Moore with Saunders & Associates.