A savory pot pie is the ultimate comfort food on a winter day. Whether you prefer to dine-in or bake a pre-made pie from your own home, here’s where you can get your pot pie fix on the North Fork.
NoFo Pot Pies
Known for his infamous pot pies, Cooperage Inn owner Jonathan Perkins decided to create his own pot pie brand, NoFo Pot Pies, in 2020. These homemade pot pies continue to be served warm at Cooperage Inn, but are also available frozen at farm stands and other locations across the North Fork to customers looking for a comforting meal at home. The pies come in a variety of traditional and seasonal flavors including chicken, turkey, short rib, vegetarian, lobster, jambalaya, shepherd’s pie and most recently, corned beef.
You can find NoFo Pot Pies at these locations:
- Cooperage Inn, 2218 Sound Ave in Baiting Hollow, 631-727-8994. You can place an order online for pickup at the NoFo Pot Pies window.
- Bakewicz Farms, 291 NY-25A in Wading River, 631-849-1120
- Duffy’s Deli, 1566 Main Road in Jamesport, 631-722-2150
- Bayview Market & Farms, 891 Main Road in Riverhead, 631-722-3077
- Country View Farm Stand, 57995 Main Road in Southold, 631-903-1335
*Note: Some of these locations are seasonal. Call ahead for business hours.
Main Road Biscuit, Jamesport
Known for its homemade biscuits, this brunch spot offers a traditional chicken pot pie topped with a house made biscuit crust.
Main Road Biscuit is located at 1601 Main Road in Jamesport. Reservations can be made for parties 8 or more at 631-779-3463, while smaller parties should check-in upon arrival.
Browder’s Birds, Mattituck
This family-owned poultry farm sells fresh, nine-inch chicken pot pies alongside organic eggs, quiches and soups at its self-serve stand. Each pot pie is homemade by Ali Katz Kitchen in Mattituck and is filled with Browder’s Birds’ certified organic, farm-raised chicken.
Browder’s Birds is located at 4050 Soundview Ave. in Mattituck, 631-477-6523.
Front Street Station, Greenport
A Front Street “must-have”, the chicken pot pie served at this cozy sit-down restaurant comes with all the works — chicken, celery, potatoes, mushrooms, white cream sauce and, most importantly, a homemade flaky crust.
Front Street Station is located at 212 Front St. in Greenport, 631-333-2050.
The Eccentric Bagel, Shelter Island
Bagels are not the only thing Eccentric Bagel is cooking up these days. At the end of last year, the Shelter Island bagel shop added to-go pot pies to its menu. Choose between chicken, short rib and lobster — each are made fresh in-house and are ready to be baked at home.
The Eccentric Bagel is located at 25 West Neck Road on Shelter Island. Pot pies should be reserved in advance — call The Eccentric Bagel at 631-749-5363 to place an order or for more information.