Sign up for our Newsletter

The sweet springtime treats from North Fork Flour Shoppe (credit: North Fork Flour Shoppe).

Cadbury who? Peeps what? There’s no need to buy products made en masse in factories to satisfy your sweet tooth on Easter.

We’ve got plenty of sweets shops and at-home bakers to take this year’s Easter basket to a whole new level.

North Fork Flour Shoppe

If you want some next level Easter and spring-themed pastries, get your orders in quick to North Fork Flour Shoppe. From the chocolate-dipped cannolis gently dusted with powdered sugar to the cupcakes that resemble little bird’s nests complete with chocolate eggs, you’ll get your sugar rush. 

Orders due by 3/31 by calling or email [email protected], 631-983-9800.

North Fork Chocolate Company

For classic chocolate Easter bunnies, check out North Fork Chocolate Company. They already have milk and white chocolate in stock, plus some cute chocolate ducks. For a touch of the North Fork, pick up some of their bright yellow chocolate sunflowers to brighten up your Easter baskets. 

740 Main Road, Aquebogue, 631-779-2963, [email protected]

Sweet Treats by Jaimie

(credit: Jaimie Schofield)

For custom cupcakes and insanely mouth watering cakes, put in an order with Sweet Treats by Jaimie. Get some spring-themed hot chocolate bombs covered in bright sprinkles, a pastel rainbow unicorn cake or floral cupcakes galore.

Order via Instagram.

North Fork Girl Chocolates

Chocolate bunnies, chocolate foiled eggs, jelly beans, chocolate dipped peeps and easter gummies — this place has it all. Stop by the shop in person or call for contactless pickup.

56340 NY-25, Southold, (631) 765-8300

Love Lane Sweet Shop

If you’re looking for the iconic pastel tin foil wrapped Easter candy, Love Lane Sweet Shop is your spot. They have chocolate eggs, bunnies, chicks, carrots and will even put together an Easter basket for you.

Credit: Love Lane Sweet Shop

125 Love Ln, Mattituck, (631) 298-2276


For some more floral in your life this spring, order the cupcakes with buttercream roses. Or for the true sweet tooth out there, get a whole cake covered with delicate, hand piped flowers.

Order via their Facebook page.