Sign up for our Newsletter

5250 Vanston Rd
Put your pending billion-dollar lottery win to good use and buy your own piece of heaven in Cutchogue.

Located on Vanston Road and listed for a cool $12.4 million, this parcel is a 1920s bayfront compound set on more than 15 acres of waterfront property.

The amenities read like a dreamer’s wish list: One thousand feet of private beach frontage, your own boat basin on Little Peconic Bay, a beach bathhouse and tennis court, a three-car garage — there’s even a separate three-bedroom, two-bath cottage.

“Ideally this would be for someone who is looking for a grand, estate-like property,” said real estate agent Carol Szynaka of Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty. “The bathhouse is right on the beach and is grandfathered in. You’d never get [permission to build] that again.”

Situated just a few hundred feet away from the beach, the property sits on beautiful, pristine land. Property belonging to The Nature Conservancy abuts it on one side, while only a few homes dot the other.

The eight-bedroom, 5.5-bath home more than matches the property’s amazing features.

“What’s special about this is that it’s unusual to find a house like this that has not been updated and ruined,” Szynaka said. “The only changes made in nearly 100 years is the kitchen and some sliding doors. Other than that, everything is original.”

The house’s large rooms are built on a grand scale, with beautiful molding lining the windows, entranceways and doors. The home features not one, but five, fireplaces. Two are on the main floor, while the other three adorn three upstairs bedrooms. Imagine the luxury of falling asleep by firelight.

“The property faces Robbin’s Island,” Szynaka said. “The back door looks right out on the bay. All the bedrooms face the water, so the sunsets are incredible. It’s like right out of a movie.”

The highlights don’t stop there. Also on the property is a separate three-bedroom cottage, perfect for overnight guests.

The parcel also includes a waterfront lot on Wunneweta Pond in the Harbor Cove Association. This property holds the tennis court, so even that amenity has its own water view.

“You can do a number of things with the land,” Szynaka said. “I’ve had inquiries from people interested in horses. Another party was interested in putting some vines on the property.”

“This is for the buyer who wants it all and can afford it all,”  she said.

See more pictures below:

$12,400,000
5250 Vanston Rd, Cutchogue
8 bedrooms, 5.55 bathrooms
6,000 square feet
Carol Szynaka
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
5250 Vanston Rd

5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
5250 Vanston Rd
Grand 1920S Bayfront Compound W/ 8 Beds, 5.5 Baths On 15.24 Acres. 1,000Ft Of Beach Frontage, Boat Basin On The Bay, Bathhouse On The Beach, 3-Bed/2-Bath Cottage, 3-Car Garage, And Clay Tennis Court. Includes A Waterfront Lot On Wunneweta Pond In Harbor Cove Association W/ Beach & Docking; 39Ft Of Bulkhead And 78Ft Of Natural Water Frontage.
See This Property »

X
X